Op-Ed Contributors
This is not end of nuke power
Updated: 2011-04-19 08:57
By Pierre Gadonneix (China Daily)
These authorities should also be entrusted with real power to investigate, control and ultimately halt the operation of a unit, a whole plant or even the development of future plants. In the short term, this will require regular and effective coordination between the national authorities to make safety not an issue for competition but rather an issue for cooperation.
In the longer term, we need to promote a truly international level of governance with a unique agency or authority which is given the power to arbitrate. We already have the means to take great steps forward to enhance and improve safety on a continuous basis.
Indeed, global institutions such as the International Atomic Energy Agency and, at the operational level, the World Association of Nuclear Operators are committed to improving nuclear safety worldwide. It is time to reinforce and enrich these existing institutions, while adapting them to the realities and new challenges of our world. This implies a reviewed legitimacy and power, and revisited objectives, missions and resources.
This approach would engender systematic sharing of experiences and enable the bar to be set on the very best business practices. In this respect, the need to understand the Fukushima accident and share the experience will be of great help to all nuclear operators and safety authorities around the world.
We are at a key stage in the growth of nuclear energy technology. As we innovate and develop the techniques that will be used to guide the next generations of reactors we need to enhance the knowledge base of our nuclear experts. Simultaneously, we have an opportunity to benchmark competence, technical understanding and processes. New safety requirements may encourage better technological and design selection. Site selection and engineering design will obviously come under renewed scrutiny with a revised view of the effects of earthquakes and tsunamis.
In the nuclear sector, safety cannot be used to provide a competitive advantage. The cost of all energy is set to increase to accommodate the enhanced safety standards rightly required by society. This will put considerable strain on the global economy, and the delay in meeting demand have the potential to stifle growth.
The new world governance on nuclear safety will have to create conditions for the adoption of this harmonious approach and shared practices. I believe this is possible. In aeronautics, for example, the safety of an aircraft is no longer a competitive advantage, because safety could be compromised in the competition between aircraft manufacturers. Companies across the world now developing airplanes respect the same safety norms in their conception, and national authorities strictly control the conditions of use. An accident in a nuclear power plant anywhere in the world has the potential to affect the entire planet. It is vital for everyone's well-being that safety conditions are equally respected around the world.
This new cooperation, and eventually new governance of nuclear safety, will allow the nuclear world to move on from the current cataclysm and overcome the swift erosion of its acceptability. In short, the nuclear sector has to regain the confidence of the public to survive.
The author is chairman of World Energy Council, an alliance of more than 90 countries, which provides an independent forum for thought-leadership committed to a sustainable energy future.
Specials
In the swim
Out of every 10 swimsuits in the world, seven are made in China.
Big spenders
Travelers spend more on shopping than food, hotels, other expenses
Rise in super rich
Rising property prices and a fast-growing economy have been the key drivers.