Shambaugh fails to defend his position
Updated: 2015-04-10 08:08
By Chen Weihua(China Daily)
|
||||||||
I didn't realize I would be missed so much so soon after leaving Washington for my home in Shanghai for holidays. Just hours after landing in Shanghai on April 2, a fellow journalist sent me a message via instant messaging service WeChat, saying David Shambaugh mentioned my name multiple times that day during his talk at George Washington University.
The talk, which I listened to days later on the Internet, was largely a crisis management for his March 7 article in The Wall Street Journal titled "The Coming Chinese Crackup", in which he declared the "endgame of the Communist rule" in China had begun.
Compared with his much criticized one-sided views in the WSJ, Shambaugh was a bit more balanced on April 2 despite his continued pessimism in China's future and his prediction that the Communist rule would end 20 years from now.
Yet the 10 challenges facing China according to Shambaugh in his talk - China at the Crossroads - are nothing new. From economic reforms, corruption to income inequality, they have been mentioned in the annual Government Work Report for years. Just a month ago, Premier Li Keqiang presented a far more comprehensive outline of the challenges in his report. Even a Beijing cab driver could elaborate some of the challenges facing the country.
The good thing, as Shambaugh admitted this time, is that top leaders are aware of these problems and taking steps to address them. But who would be naive enough to assume that a large developing country, with a population four times that of the United States and per capita GDP ranking around 90th in the world, will be free of big challenges anytime soon?
Shambaugh defended his WSJ article by blaming the newspaper for giving it a sensational headline. He said his article should be judged by its content, not title. But most people who have read his article would not endorse his conclusion based merely on random and superficial evidence. And among those people are some of the sharpest critics of China in US think tanks.
- Bird flu outbreaks reported in two Mexican states
- Failed developer shoots dead 3, injuries 2 at Milan courthouse
- People rescue beached dolphins in Japan
- Indonesian children's risky shortcut to get to school
- S.Korea, US to hold joint exercises
- Last batch of Chinese peacekeeping infantry arrives in S.Sudan
- Chinese farmers plough their lands for spring
- Tibetans' viral wedding photos contrast city with country life
- Across America over the week (from April 3 to 9)
- Battling the language barrier
- Ten photos you don't wanna miss of today
- Amur tigers come back from the brink
- Guns prepared to mark Anti-Fascist War anniversary
- Tibetans' viral wedding photos contrast city with country life
Most Viewed
Editor's Picks
What do we know about AIIB |
Full coverage of Boao Forum for Asia |
Annual legislative and political advisory sessions |
Spring Festival trends reflect a changing China |
Patent applications lead the world |
BC lures Chinese tourists |
Today's Top News
Consulate general praises C-100 on 25th anniversary
Celebrating a relationship
US, Cuba hold highest-level talks since 1961
Chinese police return favor for
ill US officer
Battling the language barrier
Hillary Clinton expected to announce presidential run soon
Apple Watch pre-orders cause backlog until summer
UN official praises new website that engages Chinese public
US Weekly
Geared to go |
The place to be |