Saving deficit, not China, threatens American dream
Updated: 2016-06-02 07:52
By STEPHEN S. ROACH(China Daily)
|
|||||||||
CAI MENG/CHINA DAILY |
US politicians invariably bemoan trade as the enemy of the middle class, the major source of pressure on jobs and wages. The current presidential campaign is no exception: Republicans and Democrats alike have taken aim at both China and the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement, holding them up as the scourge of beleaguered US workers. While this explanation may be politically expedient, the truth lies elsewhere.
When it comes to trade, as I recently argued, the United States has made its own bed. The culprit is a large saving deficit, the country has been living beyond its means for decades and drawing freely on surplus saving from abroad to fund the greatest consumption binge in history. Politicians, of course, don't want to blame voters for their profligacy; it is much easier to point the finger at others.
The saving critique merits further analysis. The data show that countries with saving deficits tend to run trade deficits, while those with saving surpluses tend to run trade surpluses. The US is the most obvious example, with a net national saving rate of 2.6 percent in late 2015-less than half the 6.3 percent average in the final three decades of the twentieth century-and trade deficits with 101 countries.
The pattern also holds true elsewhere. The United Kingdom, Canada, Finland, France, Greece, and Portugal-all of which have large trade deficits-save much less than other developed countries. Conversely, high savers like Germany, Japan, the Netherlands, Norway, Denmark, the Republic of Korea, Sweden, and Switzerland all run trade surpluses.
Saving imbalances can also lead to destabilizing international capital flows, asset bubbles, and financial crises. That was the case in the run-up to the financial crisis of 2008/2009, when global saving imbalances, as measured by the disparities between countries with current-account deficits and surpluses, hit a modern record. The asset and credit bubbles fueled by those imbalances brought the world to the brink of an abyss not seen since the 1930s.
Here, too, there is considerable finger pointing. Deficit countries tend to blame the yield-seeking "saving glut" that sloshes around in world financial markets. As former US Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke put it, if only countries like China had spent more, the bubbles that nearly broke the US would not have formed in the first place. Others have been quick to point out that the US' supposed growth miracle probably could not have happened without the capital provided by surplus countries.
The prudent approach would be to strike a better balance between saving and spending. That is particularly important for the US and China, which together account for a disproportionate share of the world's saving disparities. Simply put, the US needs to save more and consume less, while China needs to save less and consume more. To succeed, both countries will have to overcome entrenched mindsets.
On this front, China has been leading the way, with a strategy of consumer-led rebalancing that it introduced five years ago. The results so far have been mixed, as inadequate funding of a social safety net continues to temper the support to household incomes provided by services-driven job creation and urbanization-led increases in real wages. But China has lately shown a commitment to addressing this shortcoming. Its recently enacted 13th Five-Year Plan (2016-20) aims to dampen fear-driven precautionary saving through interest-rate liberalization, the introduction of deposit insurance, the loosening of the hukou residential permit system (which would improve benefit portability), and relaxation of the one-child family planning policy.
- To cool you off: The fountain in Washington Square Park
- Americans warned about terror risk this summer
- B20 China Second Joint Taskforce Meeting held in Paris
- 129 freed Myanmar fishermen brought back from India
- UN Security Council renews sanctions on South Sudan
- Cuban minister's US visit to highlight organic crops cooperation
- Photos: Little royals on the Children's Day
- Pure love: Chinese 'little prince'and his fox
- Then and now: Recreating that child-like smile
- Young teacher's heartfelt love for the students
- Photos you don't want to miss across China in May
- Robot-themed café debuts in East China's Shanghai
- Cartoon: The birth and growth of China Daily
- Students' special group photos to mark graduation
Most Viewed
Editor's Picks
Anti-graft campaign targets poverty relief |
Cherry blossom signal arrival of spring |
In pictures: Destroying fake and shoddy products |
China's southernmost city to plant 500,000 trees |
Cavers make rare finds in Guangxi expedition |
Cutting hair for Longtaitou Festival |
Today's Top News
Chinese stocks surge on back of MSCI rumors
Liang avoids jail in shooting death
China's finance minister addresses ratings downgrade
Duke alumni visit Chinese Embassy
Marriott unlikely to top Anbang offer for Starwood: Observers
Chinese biopharma debuts on Nasdaq
What ends Jeb Bush's White House hopes
Investigation for Nicolas's campaign
US Weekly
Geared to go |
The place to be |