Judge rules ‘Haager-Dasz’ is trademark infringement
Updated: 2012-12-03 19:53
By Yang Yao (chinadaily.com.cn)
|
|||||||||
A court in Beijing has confiscated the “Haager-Dasz” trademark from a clothing manufacturer, saying the public would confuse the name with the well-known Haagen-Dazs ice cream.
Beijing No 1 Intermediate People’s Court on Dec 3 made a ruling in favor of General Mills Co, the American food corporation, which sought to remove the trademark from clothing.
On June 3, 2003, a manufacturer applied to register “Haager-Dasz” as a trademark for clothing items. General Mills, the owner of the Haagen-Dazs brand, raised objections with the trade appeal board of the State Administration for Industry and Commerce.
The board found that the materials provided by General Mills failed to prove that it has been “well-known in China’s relevant public with high reputation” and therefore granted the Haager-Dasz registration.
General Mills appealed the board’s decision to the court.
The court found the ice cream mark is a well-known brand, and the disputed trademark, which is an imitation of Haagen-Dazs, would mislead the public and create confusion.
The court ruled against the board and told it to quash its original ruling.
Judge Cui Xuefeng said that the ruling was intended to stop speculative enterprises from maliciously registering trademarks.
"Haagen-Dazs already has a high reputation and prominence in the Chinese market and should have been recognized as a well-known brand,” Cui said. “The clothing manufacturer made only minor changes to the wording of the mark. Its intention is obviously malicious.”
The court on the same day recognized five other trademarks as well-known: the vehicle Jeep, the milk powder Dumex, the condiment Totole, the oven-goods maker Vatti, and Tsinghua University.
Cui said that the low cost of trademark registration and the high profits possible are the motivation of copyright abuse. Some corporations, lawyers and agents even specialize in malicious registration and sell the marks later to earn quick money.
"No one is entitled to warehouse potentially useful marks as there is a regulation in trademark law that non-use for three consecutive years is evidence of abandonment,” Cui said. “Trademark law only protects marks that are being used. ”
The judge proposed to expand the scope of protection in regard to well-known trademarks in his recently published research report.
"For example, the characters in books or movies are sometimes registered as trademarks,” Cui said. “They should also be under protection.”
According to the judge, since the launch of the Trademark Law in 2001, Beijing No 1 Intermediate’s Court has accepted a total of 8,780 trademark dispute cases, and 1,173 cases among them claimed their marks as well-known ones. However, only 109 trademarks are recognized as well-known ones.
"When determining whether a trademark is well-known, judges should use not only quantitative methods to measure its market share, but consider overall factors from a general consumer’s point of view,” the judge said.
- Better copyright protection urged
- Apple appeals China Encyclopedia copyright ruling
- Apple to pay $80,250 in copyright row
- After a long review, latest draft of new copyright law
- Copyright protection winning battle against piracy
- Court finds copyright of Buddha design valid
- Chinese writers sue Apple for copyright violation
- Apple ordered to pay $83,000 in copyright suit
- Writers win copyright lawsuit against Baidu
- The influence on music industry from the Copyright Law revision
- Breaking the mold to protect copyrights
- Court: Peking Opera logo violated artist's copyright
- Growth in industries based on copyrights
- Relief reaches isolated village
- Rainfall poses new threats to quake-hit region
- Funerals begin for Boston bombing victims
- Quake takeaway from China's Air Force
- Obama celebrates young inventors at science fair
- Earth Day marked around the world
- Volunteer team helping students find sense of normalcy
- Ethnic groups quick to join rescue efforts
Most Viewed
Editor's Picks
Supplies pour into isolated villages |
All-out efforts to save lives |
American abroad |
Industry savior: Big boys' toys |
New commissioner
|
Liaoning: China's oceangoing giant |
Today's Top News
Health new priority for quake zone
Xi meets US top military officer
Japan's boats driven out of Diaoyu
China mulls online shopping legislation
Bird flu death toll rises to 22
Putin appoints new ambassador to China
Japanese ships blocked from Diaoyu Islands
Inspired by Guan, more Chinese pick up golf
US Weekly
Beyond Yao
|
Money power |