Buffett guests realize there is no free lunch
Updated: 2012-06-14 08:08
By Ma Liyao (China Daily)
|
|||||||||
Clockwise from top: Hedge fund manager Zhao Danyang and his son Zhao Ziyang with billionaire investor Warren Buffett after placing the winning bid in a charity auction for lunch with Buffett. Buffett, the chairman of Berkshire Hathaway, handed his wallet to the younger Zhao and then whispered a stock tip after completing a series of television interviews. Buffett's power lunch is traditionally held at the high-end New York steakhouse, Smith & Wollensky. The restaurant donates $10,000 to the charity Glide for the pleasure of hosting the event annually. Warren Buffett and Wang Chuanfu, CEO of the auto and battery maker BYD, presenting a key to the millionth person to own a BYD car on Sept 27, 2010. Provided to China Daily |
Seat at the table with 'Oracle of Omaha' is not cheap but it is for a good cause, Ma Liyao reports in Beijing.
Having hosted his annual charity "power lunch" for high-flying, well-heeled investors for the past 13 years, Warren Buffett may be forgiven for not remembering the name of each and every guest, despite their huge outlay to gain a seat at the table - this year's top bidder shelled out a cool $3,456,789 for the pleasure of spending three hours in the company of the chairman of the investment house Berkshire Hathaway.
However, one name the 81-year-old US investment guru is unlikely to forget is that of Zhao Danyang, who not only introduced the notoriously abstemious Buffett to the pleasures of China's famous, and famously expensive, rice spirit Moutai and the health tonic Dong'e Ejiao, but also changed the nature of the event forever.
Before 2008, when Zhao won his place at the table with a bid of $2.1 million, the lucky winner was allowed to quiz the "Oracle of Omaha", as Buffett is known, on topics ranging from shares and investment combinations to food, music, philanthropy and even girlfriends.
All that changed after Zhao, the manager of a Hong Kong-based hedge fund, took the chance to recommend two individual shares - the supermarket chain Wumart Commercial and the auto and battery maker BYD, both listed on the Hong Kong Stock exchange - to Buffett, who agreed to take a look at them.
That simple expression of interest moved the market, causing strong share-price volatility. Zhao's hedge fund, Pure Heart Asset Management, benefited to the tune of $16 million in the four days that followed the lunch as it offloaded shares of Wumart Commercial. Zhao wasn't the only winner, though, as shares in both Guizhou Maotai and Dong'e Ejiao also surged on the back of the association with Buffett.
As far as Zhao was concerned, the lunch came cheap. The man known as the "Godfather of Chinese Private Equity" reasoned that $2.1 million was a small price to pay, compared with the money he was able to earn from the lessons he learned during the three-hour meal.
"Successful investment revolves around making the right judgment at the right time. Talking to Buffett for those three hours helped me solve some problems that have been puzzling me for years. I'm very happy about that," he said later.
The "Buffett effect" proved to be short lived, however. Just two years later, Zhao had to apologize for the poor performance of the funds he managed.
In a 2010 letter to investors, he noted that Pure Heart Value Investment Fund's yearly return on investment was 0.5 percent, and Pure Heart Natural Selection Fund's yearly return was minus 8 percent.
All for charity
Buffett's power lunch, traditionally held in a high-end New York steakhouse called Smith & Wollensky - which itself donates $10,000 to the cause for the pleasure of hosting the event annually - is legendary in the world of finance. When it started in 2000, interested parties simply had to fork out a paltry $25,000 for the food and the table talk. Today the price has risen more than 138-fold.
Given the fragile state of the US economic recovery - unemployment rose to 8.2 percent in May - and Buffett's announcement that he had been diagnosed with prostate cancer, the scale of this year's winning bid astonished many observers and bucked a run of low bids in the five-day auction process.
Observers adopted a cautious wait-and-see attitude as the bids rose slowly during the first four days of the five-day event. The last bid on June 7, the penultimate day of the auction, was just $410,000.
However, the proceedings saw a dramatic change on the final day as the amounts offered surged in the last 15 minutes of bidding, from $1,234,467 to a record-breaking $3,456,689 when proceedings wrapped up at 7:30 pm on June 8. Thus far, the only information available about the winner is their eBay ID, s***7 and their nationality is unknown.
Duan Yongping, the founder of both Subor Electronics Industry Corp and BBK Electronics Group, submitted a winning bid of $620,100 in 2006 and became the first Chinese to join the charity lunch.
In a video interview with the Internet portal Netease conducted soon after the meal, Duan said he did not think it was accurate to say that he had spent $620,100 on the meal.
"Actually no one paid for the lunch, except maybe Mr. Buffett himself because he tipped. It was more of a charity activity. He was helping the Glide Foundation (a nonprofit organization that provides aid for the homeless in San Francisco). We just had the chance to sit down and chat. It wasn't a business deal, so you can't say it was a loss or a gain," said Duan, an active philanthropist in China and co-founder of a nonprofit charity called Enlight in the US.
"And you cannot simply say that it was or wasn't expensive. I once did a rough calculation of Mr. Buffett's average hourly earnings and the number was around $3 million. My $620,100 secured lunch with him for more than three hours," said Duan.
Admitting that the lunch turned out to be very rewarding, even though he had not had any specific expectations, Duan said that afterwards his investment strategy remained almost unchanged.
Activity in China
Buffett once told investors, "The 19th century belonged to England, the 20th century belonged to the US and the 21st century belongs to China. Invest accordingly." However his own business activity in China has been limited, so far, and many investors are waiting for him to take his own advice.
Buffett has previously invested in the oil and gas producer PetroChina, and Berkshire Hathaway currently has a 10 percent interest in the aforementioned BYD, whose name stands for "Build Your Dreams".
In March this year, he announced plans to invest in a corporate aircraft joint venture in Zhuhai, Guangdong province, but that seems to be the limit of his involvement in the world's second-largest economy.
Despite this, the famously unostentatious Buffett is a familiar figure to many Chinese, partly through his visits to the country that have raised his profile with the general public and investors alike, and partly because of his, some would say bizarre, prerecorded appearance on China Central Television's New Year Gala, where he played the ukulele and sang a song about railroads.
However, apart from financial gain and a possible career boost - Ted Weschler, a 50-year-old former hedge-fund managing partner from Charlottesville, Virginia, who won the lunch auction in both 2010 and 2011, joined Berkshire Hathaway this year to help oversee the company's investment portfolio - most investors who expressed an interest in joining Buffett's table see it as an opportunity to learn from a world-class master of investment.
"It would definitely be good for me, if I ever get the chance to listen to Buffett's opinions face-to-face," according to Lu Wei, president of Mingyuan Investment Consulting Corp, who said that Buffett's investment strategy is not complicated, but few people really understand it.
Liu Jialei, a private investor who followed this year's lunch auction avidly, said few of the bidders in the initial auction 13 years ago would have guessed that the price would skyrocket. "I don't think that there is any real secret to Buffett's success. He just is able to stick to his simple investment principles," opined Liu.
Not every observer is convinced by Buffett, though. Wu Xiaobo, a Chinese finance writer, said the auction was like a show. "To understand Buffett's investing wisdom, reading a couple of books carefully is a better choice than a lunch. Very few substantial changes have happened after the bid winners had lunch with Buffett," he commented.
Meanwhile, Zhou Yixing, a Chinese observer whose blog is published on the website of the Hong Kong-based Phoenix TV, wrote that the true focus of Buffett's lunch auction should not be on the price, but on its nature that perfectly combines a commercial auction with social charity.
That view was amplified by the US investment legend Michael Steinhardt, who in April bashed Buffett and his hedge fund on a program on the US business TV channel, CNBC. "[Buffett's] reality is he is the greatest PR person of recent times and he has managed to achieve a snow job that has conned virtually everyone in the press to my knowledge," said Steinhardt.
China to take up the reins?
Despite the skepticism in some quarters, in the past 13 auctions Buffett has raised more than $11.5 million for the Glide Foundation, making the charity the biggest winner. Combining commerce platforms with charity works is becoming a growing practice.
Tyler Spalding, a corporate social responsibility professional from Edelman, the public relations company for eBay, which conducted the Buffett auction, said that he believed commercial platforms should empower and encourage people to support the causes they most care about.
"We think they are a really innovative way for nonprofits to leverage their high-profile relationships to raise unrestricted funds to support their mission," said Spalding.
That message appears to have gained some momentum in China. Umiwi.com, an emerging web TV company, initiated a similar lunch auction in 2010, selling a three-hour lunch date with Shi Yuzhu, the CEO of the software maker, Giant Interactive Group.
The bids eventually peaked at 1,899,999 yuan ($298,300). The funds raised were donated to the Happiness Project, a charity that helps to fund poor mothers in Southwest China.
Wang Lifen, editor in chief of Umiwi, said that the auction was held primarily to raise funds for charity, but admitted that it had brought in good publicity for the fledgling website. The auction has now become an annual event. Yuan Dibao, the president of a construction company in Shanghai, won in 2011 with a bid of 1,960,000 yuan.
In the light of China's economic rise during the past decade and the growing number of extremely wealthy individuals in the country, the stage may be set for them to organize their own "Buffett auctions" and emulate the US billionaire in more than just financial power.
Contact the reporter at maliyao@chinadaily.com.cn
Wang Jingshu in New York contributed to this story.
Relief reaches isolated village
Rainfall poses new threats to quake-hit region
Funerals begin for Boston bombing victims
Quake takeaway from China's Air Force
Obama celebrates young inventors at science fair
Earth Day marked around the world
Volunteer team helping students find sense of normalcy
Ethnic groups quick to join rescue efforts
Most Viewed
Editor's Picks
![]()
|
![]()
|
![]()
|
![]()
|
![]()
|
![]()
|
Today's Top News
Health new priority for quake zone
Xi meets US top military officer
Japan's boats driven out of Diaoyu
China mulls online shopping legislation
Bird flu death toll rises to 22
Putin appoints new ambassador to China
Japanese ships blocked from Diaoyu Islands
Inspired by Guan, more Chinese pick up golf
US Weekly
![]()
|
![]()
|